On Tuesday, when the story first surfaced, it sounded sensational. So much so it even made headlines nationwide.
18-year-old Christian Phillips was arrested for delivering drug-tainted cookies to North Texas police stations. He had been on community service for a previous charge, and claimed delivering the cookies was part of his sentence. Cops at first laughed at that explanation.
One officer called him “an idiot.”
Reporters jumped on the story. No doubt, this was news, and the cops got the bad guy in jail. But that was just the first chapter. Like a good novel, this story had a few surprise twists.
Sophisticated lab tests contradicted earlier field tests, and showed there were no drugs in the cookies after all. And after a day of confusion, it turned out that his explanation (about the community service) was true.
ASSAULTING A POLICE OFFICER
The tale starts in July 2007 in Watauga. A bunch of teenagers, including him, threw a loud party in an apartment in Watauga. Someone called the cops.
When officers responded, they say, several teens ran out the back. Police say Phillips tried to close the front door and got in a brief scuffle with an officer. He was charged with assaulting the officer. The officer was not hurt.
It was his first brush with the law.
A judge sentenced him to 80 hours community service with Mothers Against Drunk Driving. MADD told him to deliver cookies to area police stations. Cookies for cops, they call it.![](https://gordongabs.wordpress.com/wp-content/uploads/2008/07/cookies1.png?w=300&h=224)
DELIVERING COOKIES
Phillips made a list of area police stations and addresses. He made the cookies and started delivering them, doing exactly what he was supposed to do.
When he got to Blue Mound, police there gladly accepted the cookies. He left. Police later noticed the cookies smelled of marijuana.
Police say a field test was positive for marijuana. An alert went out to other area departments to be on the lookout for this guy with tainted cookies.
ARREST IN LAKE WORTH
The next day, Tuesday, Phillips delivered a basket of cookies to Lake Worth. Detectives there detained him.
They also said the cookies reeked of marijuana. They said a drug dog alerted on the cookies, his car, and $2000 cash he had with him.
Then, the first curious twist: A field test in Lake Worth was positive not for marijuana, but LSD.
He denied tainting the cookies and told police his friends may have been smoking marijuana when he was baking the cookies, so that’s why they smelled, police said.
But police didn’t believe him and arrested him. He was charged with tampering with a food product.
CAR SEARCH
Lake Worth Police also obtained a search warrant to look inside his car.
In the trunk, police say they found a scale, plastic baggies, and small traces of marijuana. But not enough to charge him with possession.
OTHER POLICE DEPARTMENTS REACT
Meanwhile, other police departments began to wonder if he had delivered cookies to them.
Turns out, he had delivered the treats to police in Fort Worth and Watauga and other cities also. As many as 10 officers in those cities who ate the cookies went for blood tests. None showed symptoms, and the blood tests were all negative.
FURTHER TESTS
The case began to crumble when more in-depth tests at the Tarrant County Medical Examiner’s Office (they have the lab) showed no drugs in the cookies at all.
How could those field tests have turned up positive for marijuana and LSD? They are called “presumptive” tests, and they are not conclusive. Apparently they’re not that reliable, and they are not admissible in court.
WHO’S TO BLAME?
His attorney, Patrick Davis, blamed the media on his way out of the Lake Worth police station Wednesday. “You guys already convicted my client,” he said, refusing to stop.
In fairness to us, we didn’t even know about the caper until he was already in jail. We reported the news as best we knew it.
And when the news came out that the Medical Examiner’s tests were negative, we reported that as prominently as we did his arrest.
Police say they acted based on the circumstances they knew at the time.
CHARGES DROPPED
Late Thursday afternoon, police dropped all charges against Phillips. He walked out of jail shortly before 6 pm, got in his father’s car and drove off. He had nothing to say to waiting reporters.
Asked if he thought he owed Phillips an apology, Lake Worth Police Chief Brett McGuire said any department would have handled the case the same way.
“Am I sorry that this young man was detained for coming up on three days while we went through this? Yes, I certainly am,” McGuire said.